In the vast annals of cricket, few players have captured the imagination like Ben Stokes. A match-winner, a game-changer, and a hero in the eyes of many, especially for those who bleed England’s cricketing colours. Yet, beneath the dazzling array of his cricketing talents, questions arise. As much as cricket is a game of individual skill, it’s also a team sport. One where a player’s decisions off the field can be just as impactful as those made on it. Recently, Stokes has been under the lens not for his extraordinary abilities but rather for decisions that put his interests above those of his team and franchise. While he’s been a key figure in England’s cricketing successes, including the unforgettable 2019 World Cup win, some argue that his recent actions have been in stark contrast to the team spirit that underpins the sport. Two instances, in particular, have fanned the flames of this discussion: his sudden return from ODI retirement just before the World Cup 2023 and his questionable commitment to the Indian Premier League (IPL) team that bought him for a hefty sum. Here’s a deep dive into why some fans and critics are starting to view Ben Stokes as a king of ‘U-Turn’.
Ben Stokes: The Question of U-Turn in a Team Sport:
1. An Abrupt U-Turn on ODI Retirement
Firstly, let’s consider the dramatic return from ODI retirement. Last year, Stokes made headlines when he announced his ODI retirement to focus on Test and T20 cricket. When questioned a month ago about the possibility of making a return to ODI cricket, he outright rejected the idea. Yet, a day before the announcement of England’s preliminary World Cup 2023 squad, Stokes surprised everyone by making himself available.
The timing raises eyebrows for several reasons. This sudden change of heart didn’t just happen at any time; it happened right before a World Cup. Such decisions have repercussions. Indeed, the talented Harry Brook lost his spot to accommodate Stokes in the squad. While Stokes’ abilities are not in question, the last-minute nature of this reversal could potentially disrupt team dynamics. It begs the question: is Stokes placing his desires above the team’s long-term planning and the careers of upcoming players?
2. Questionable IPL Commitment
The second issue at hand revolves around his IPL stint in 2023. The Chennai Super Kings (CSK) secured his services for a whopping 16 crores. However, Stokes chose to sit out for 90% of the tournament. Now, that in itself could be excusable due to injuries or personal reasons. But what raised red flags is that he returned to action soon after the IPL, representing England in a Test series against Ireland.
This isn’t a one-time occurrence. Stokes has displayed this tendency with his earlier franchises as well. Such a pattern sends a wrong message, not just to the franchise that invests heavily in him, but also to the young talents who idolize him. The IPL is more than a lucrative gig; it’s a platform that unites various talents and nurtures young players. When a player of Stokes’ calibre opts out so casually, it undermines the spirit and the business model of the league.
3. The Moeen Ali Episode
Thirdly, let’s examine Stokes’ influence on Moeen Ali’s career decisions. During his stint with CSK in IPL 2023, Stokes apparently persuaded Moeen Ali to come out of Test retirement to play in the Ashes. Ali obliged, played in the series, and then went back into retirement. Moeen Ali humorously mentioned that he would ignore any future pleas from Stokes to unretire. While it may seem like a light-hearted incident, it sheds light on Stokes’ influence to sway decisions that could affect the structure and long-term plans of the English Test side.
ALSO READ: 2 Reasons Why Adam Zampa Will Be One Of The Highest Wicket Takers In The World Cup
