The second Test match between India and Australia at the Adelaide Oval has been a rollercoaster of emotions for Indian cricket fans, particularly in the context of Rohit Sharma’s performance and captaincy. Following a hiatus from the first Test, where India secured a convincing 295-run victory under the temporary captaincy of Jasprit Bumrah, Rohit Sharma returned to lead the team in the second Test. His absence from the first match was due to the joyous occasion of welcoming a baby boy on November 15, missing the subsequent match on November 22. However, Sharma’s return was overshadowed by an underwhelming performance on the field.
In this match, Australia, initially struggling at 191-5, was propelled to a significant lead of 157 runs thanks to Travis Head’s explosive 140. India’s second innings was a struggle, culminating in a total of 175, setting a meager target of 19 runs for Australia. The only bright spot in India’s batting was Nitish Kumar Reddy, who scored a resilient 42 runs. Amidst this backdrop, Sharma’s contribution was notably lackluster.
Rohit Sharma needs this level of hate pic.twitter.com/wL9MmlKjR4
β sarthhhh (@ChiefLahk) December 7, 2024
Rohit Sharma should leave test captaincy for sanity of Indian Cricket and it Fans…there’s no shame in accepting that you aren’t cut for the job!!
He’s mind boggling awful!
β Gagan Chawla (@toecrushrzzz) December 7, 2024
Random Cricket Stat: Nitish Reddy has more runs in his first four Test innings than Rohit Sharma in his last twelve. 12! And he’s the captain. His average isn’t even 12 in the last 12 innings. God save us!
β Tushar Gupta (@Tushar15_) December 8, 2024
-Can’t bat
-Can’t field
-Can’t captain
-Can’t respect veteran players
-Eat’s 10 vadapav’s daily
-Play’s for the opponentRohit DuckMan π¦ sharma burden to team Indiaπ
Please retire Hippo ππ»#INDvsAUS pic.twitter.com/cMlMCHJQP1
β Praneeth VKΒΉβΈ (@fantasy_d11) December 8, 2024
Nitish Reddy hasn’t gotten a single over since he took marnus wicket. Rohit Sharma the greatest captain with yet another captaincy masterclass.
β VINAY (@SimplyWazza) December 7, 2024
Like this Post if you think Rohit Sharma should retire pic.twitter.com/CsamOBqDg2
β Krishna. (@KrishVK_18) December 6, 2024
This might sound harsh to some Rohit fans but Rohit Sharma is a pretty ordinary test captain. He unwillingly carries a negative aura which doesn’t let the bowlers to bring that energy on the field. Kohli and Bumrah are great examples of how a test captain should be.
β Himanshu (@chase__master) December 6, 2024
Rohit Sharma: I want captaincy in the next match as well.
Gautam Gambhir: pic.twitter.com/s83RWFARD7
β narsa. (@rathor7_) December 8, 2024
Night watchman Rohit Sharma has gone π pic.twitter.com/qddxGnKvay
β πΌ (@Criminal_Gogo14) December 7, 2024
Rohit Sharma now has the lowest batting average by an Indian Test captain in a season.
12 innings
142 runs
11.83 average #INDvsAUS pic.twitter.com/pIyJqxm3yCβ Madhav Sharma (@HashTagCricket) December 8, 2024
Indian bowling unit –
Without Rohit With Rohit Sharma pic.twitter.com/9pJo3bcPAp
β ` (@chixxsays) December 6, 2024
Playing at number 6, a position necessitated by KL Rahul opening, Rohit Sharma managed only 3 runs in the first innings and a mere 6 in the second. This has not only raised eyebrows but has also sparked a wave of criticism from fans and pundits alike. Sharma’s inability to score significantly has put him under the microscope, especially in a series where every run counts. His strategic decisions as captain, particularly in terms of bowling changes and field placements, have also been dissected, with some fans expressing disappointment over what they perceive as a lack of innovative thinking or adaptability to the game’s demands.
The fan reaction has been palpable across social media platforms, with many expressing frustration over Sharma’s form and leadership. While some argue that his record as an opener and captain in other series justifies his position, the immediate context of this match sees fans and critics alike questioning his effectiveness. The pressure is not just on Rohit Sharma as a batsman but also as a captain, where decisions like not utilizing Jasprit Bumrah optimally in the first session on Day 2 or the delayed introduction of spin bowler Ravichandran Ashwin have been debated.
In defense of Rohit Sharma, one must consider the broader picture: his track record, the morale boost from his return to the team post a personal milestone, and the challenging Australian conditions. Yet, the immediacy of cricket often demands instant results, and Sharma’s performance in this Test has not met those expectations. The scrutiny over his captaincy and batting form is a reminder of the high stakes in international cricket, where every game can define a player’s legacy.
The match at Adelaide has not only been about scores on the board but about leadership under pressure. Rohit Sharma’s journey in this series is a narrative of highs and lows, where his performance and captaincy decisions have indeed triggered a spectrum of reactions from fans. How he and the team respond in the coming matches will be crucial, not just for the series outcome but for Sharma’s standing as a leader and batsman in Indian cricket.